Background Endoscopic intracerebral hemorrhage (ICH) evacuation techniques have gained interest as a potential therapeutic option. However, the instrumentation and techniques employed are still being refined to optimize hemostasis and evacuation efficiency.
Objective We describe the application of a specific endoscopic technique in the treatment of ICH called the Stereotactic Intracerebral Hemorrhage Underwater Blood Aspiration (SCUBA) technique. It differs from previously described minimally invasive ICH interventions in that it combines two separate neuroendoscopic strategies in two phases, the first under dry-field conditions and the second using a wet-field strategy.
Methods All patients who underwent endoscopic ICH evacuation with the SCUBA technique from December 2015 to September 2017 were included.
Results The SCUBA technique was performed in 47 patients. The average evacuation percentage was 88.2% (SD 20.8). Active bleeding identified to derive from a specific source was observed in 23 (48.9%) cases. Active bleeding was addressed with irrigation alone in five cases (10.6%) and required electrocautery in 18 cases (38.3%). Intraoperative bleeding occurred in 3 patients (6.4%) and postoperative bleeding occurred in a single case (2.1%).
Conclusions The SCUBA technique provides surgeons with a defined strategy for true endoscopic hematoma evacuation. In particular, the fluid-filled cavity in SCUBA Phase 2 has the potential to provide several advantages over the traditional air-filled strategy, including clear identification and cauterization of bleeding vessels and visualization of residual clot burden. Further investigation is necessary to compare this technique to others that are currently used.
- Subarachnoid Hemorrhage
This is an Open Access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Spontaneous ICH is a devastating and deadly form of stroke with mortality rates in excess of 40%.1 2 Trials investigating the benefit of open craniotomy and evacuation have demonstrated no discernible difference in functional outcome between the surgical and medical treatment groups.3 4 However, more recent trials aimed at avoiding the invasive shortcomings of the open craniotomy trials with minimally invasive strategies, such as MISTIE II and ICES, have produced promising findings.5–7 Despite this effort, current minimally invasive techniques do not permit clear visualization of residual clot burden, nor do they permit reliable visualization and cauterization of active arterial bleeding. Here, we present a novel neuroendoscopic technique called Stereotactic ICH Underwater Blood Aspiration (SCUBA), which aims to address these shortcomings with the use of a fluid-filled cavity.
All patients who underwent endoscopic ICH evacuation with the SCUBA technique from December 2015 to September 2017 were included in this retrospective case series. The indications and patient eligibility criteria used include the following: hematoma volume >20 cc, hematoma volume stability on two CT scans 6 hours apart, National Institutes of Health Stroke Scale (NIHSS)≥6, Glasgow Coma Score (GCS)≥4, and baseline modified Rankin Score (mRS) <4. Full inclusion and exclusion criteria can be found in online supplementary appendix 1.
Supplementary file 1
Using preoperative CT and postoperative day 1 CT, ICH volumes were calculated using the ABC/2 method.8 Volume calculations were performed by a medical student (author AGC) member of the surgical team with training and close oversight from the senior authors (authors JM and CPK). Data describing the number of bleeding vessels encountered and the techniques employed to obtain hemostasis were gathered from the operative report as detailed by the operating surgeons (authors JM and CPK).
IRB study approval and patient consent for the illustrative case example were obtained.
The Apollo System (Penumbra Inc., Alameda, California) was approved in 2014 by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for use in the evacuation of intraventricular hemorrhage and the indication has since expanded to cover ICH. It is comprised of an aspiration-irrigation apparatus that is connected to the Apollo wand. The Apollo wand has an outer diameter of 2.6 mm that is easily accommodated within the central port of an endoscope. It contains an agitator wire within its lumen that can be activated with a foot pedal to pulverize clot material. This helps to maintain patency of the slender lumen during aspiration.
SCUBA (Stereotactic ICH Underwater Blood Aspiration)
Positioning and planning
Using preoperative volumetric imaging, a line is extended through the long axis of the clot to the nearest skull surface to maximize hematoma access in a single dimension while minimizing the traversed brain (figure 1). The location of prominent vasculature is taken into account when planning the entry point. The majority of supratentorial hemorrhages arise from the basal ganglia or thalamus, which are typically approached with the patient supine and the incision anterior to the coronal suture. Incisions below the hairline are accepted with care to avoid the midline and the frontal sinus. Various navigational systems are available, each with their own advantages and disadvantages.9 We prefer the Medtronic StealthStation AxiEM (Medtronic, Minneapolis, MN, USA) frameless, pinless electromagnetic system to avoid the line-of-sight limitations of alternative optical systems and the need for pinning or the attachment of a registration post, which improves the quality of the intraoperative CT.
A 3 cm linear, horizontal incision is made and a high-speed drill with a 5 mm cutting burr is used to create a 1.5 cm diameter craniectomy. When the trajectory is not perfectly perpendicular to the skull, extra care must be taken to drill away a cylinder in the bone along the planned trajectory to maximize mobility of the sheath and endoscope within the craniectomy. Hemostasis is attained with bone wax, gel foam, and bipolar cautery. Prior to dural incision, ultrasound may be used to confirm the hematoma size and location for comparison after evacuation. The dura is incised in a cruciate fashion and cauterized to within 1–2 mm of the bone edge. The insertion point is most often made in a gyrus to ensure full visibility of nearby vessels, which are carefully avoided. A pial incision is made and hemostasis is attained.
A 19-Fr introducer sheath is inserted along the planned trajectory with the AxiEM stylet positioned within the sheath to provide live feedback on the location of its tip. The trajectory is planned such that the tip of the sheath will rest 1.5 cm from the distal end of the hematoma (figure 2). At this target point, the introducer and the navigation probe are removed. The depth of the sheath is noted, marked at the level of the skin, and held in place by the assistant surgeon. The Storz (Tuttlingen, Germany) rigid endoscope is inserted. The Apollo wand is inserted in the center port and held in the opposite hand (figure 3). The suction strength on the Apollo system is set to moderate or high during this initial phase of evacuation. As described previously by Fiorella and colleagues, the suction catheter remains within the distal 1 cm of the sheath, aspirating liquid hematoma that presents itself in the end of the sheath (video 1).10
After the hematoma in this region is aspirated, reduced mass effect causes the surrounding brain to collapse inward and come into view at the end of the sheath. Once this occurs, the sheath is gently pivoted at the same depth to explore laterally to the sides of the hematoma cavity (video 2). Once the operator is convinced there is no remaining hematoma at that depth, the sheath is drawn back 1.5 cm and the process is repeated. If, during this phase, a solid clot is encountered, the agitator wire within the Apollo wand is activated to digest large pieces. Occasionally, a formed clot is too large for the device and adheres to its tip. In this case, the entire endoscope and Apollo wand are removed together, with care not to dislodge the corked clot within the sheath (video 3).
After clearing all visible clots by withdrawing incrementally from the distal end of the hematoma, the signature step of the SCUBA technique is performed by infusing the cavity with normal saline from a reservoir bag suspended ~25 cm above the level of the patient’s head. This saline infuses passively through a fully opened side port while the second side port also remains fully open to permit passive egress of saline. This prevents pressurization of the cavity. With the saline freely flowing, the cavity is sufficiently expanded to permit fluid-filled exploration of the entire cavity under direct visualization. At first, blood products may obstruct visibility, but will clear after 1–5 min with continuous irrigation. The suction is set to low (~25%) for this portion of the case to permit aspiration of blood on the wall of the cavity without damaging the nearby brain matter (video 4). If the blood does not completely clear, it may be the indication of an active bleeder. Tendrils of extravasating blood declare themselves as they diffuse from the walls into the fluid-filled cavity. Active bleeders can be addressed in several ways, including continuous irrigation, pressure from the endoscope sheath or endoscopic instrument, or cautery with an endoscopic bipolar electrode. For active bleeders that will not clear with irrigation alone, we find the bipolar cautery to be the most effective instrument due to its rigidity and ease of navigation within view of the endoscope (video 5). After bleeders are controlled, the cavity becomes clear, permitting aspiration of smaller residual pieces of clot along the sides or in crevices of the cavity.
Assessment and closure
After aspiration of all visible clots, the sheath is removed and the burr hole ultrasound can be used to assess for residual hematoma. The ultrasound may be helpful to reassess the degree of evacuation and settle any doubt about questionable regions seen with the endoscope. Intraoperative CT is then performed prior to closure to confirm that the goal of greater than 80% of the hematoma has been evacuated. If the CT demonstrates that the residual clot volume is greater than 20% of the original volume, then a second pass is made with the introducer and sheath.
After satisfactory intra-operative imaging has been obtained, hemostatic gel foam is placed in the burr hole over the surface of the brain. A titanium plate is used to cover the craniectomy defect and is secured in place with titanium screws. The galea and subcutaneous layers are closed with 3–0 Vicryl. A 4–0 Monocryl subcuticular stitch is used to close the skin, followed by Steri-Strips.
Illustrative case example
The patient is an 87-year-old male with hypertension, hyperlipidemia, and coronary artery disease who presented with lethargy, left-sided hemiplegia, and left-sided neglect. On arrival at the emergency department, the patient had a GCS of 10, NIHSS of 23, and ICH score of 4. A CT scan was performed, revealing a large, right parietal ICH measuring 91cc with intraventricular extension (figure 4A–C). He was intubated, a right frontal EVD was placed, and he was transferred to our hospital, where he underwent minimally invasive clot evacuation 24 hours post-ictus. A trajectory was planned using stereotactic guidance and a right parietal burr hole was made. Pre-evacuation burr-hole ultrasound demonstrated presence of the hematoma in the expected location (figure 5A–B).
SCUBA Phase 1 is demonstrated in the accompanying videos showing aspiration within the end of the sheath under dry-field conditions (video 1). It continues with observation of the brain closing in around the end of the sheath, lateral maneuvering of the sheath to explore the sidewalls of the cavity, and incremental retraction of the sheath (video 2). A large piece of clotted blood was found and removed by retracting the aspiration device and endoscope together (video 3). During SCUBA Phase 2, the residual clot was aspirated from the cavity walls with gentle aspiration (video 4). Active bleeding was encountered and treated with continuous irrigation and bipolar cautery (video 5). Post-evacuation ultrasound (figure 5C–D) and intraoperative CT (figure 5E–F) confirmed >90% evacuation. Postoperative CT demonstrated 99% evacuation with <1 cc residual hematoma (figure 4D–F).
The patient had a dramatic improvement to a NIHSS of 11 on postoperative day 1 and continued to improve throughout his hospitalization. Neither tracheostomy nor percutaneous gastrostomy tube placement was required during his recovery. The EVD was weaned effectively and he did not require a ventriculoperitoneal (VP) shunt prior to discharge. He was discharged on postoperative day 10 with a NIHSS of 4. He continued to improve in acute rehabilitation and at 3-month follow-up had a NIHSS of 0 and a mRS of 1 for minor balance difficulties. At 6-month follow-up he had returned to his work as a concert pianist full-time and was without neurological deficits (NIHSS 0, mRS 0).
Experience with the SCUBA technique
A total of 47 patients underwent neuroendoscopic ICH evacuation via the SCUBA technique. Mean preoperative ICH volume was 42.6cc (SD 29.7) and mean postoperative ICH volume was 4.2cc (SD 6.6), amounting to an average evacuation rate of 88.2% (SD 20.8) (table 1). Active bleeding vessels were encountered during SCUBA Phase 2 in 23 cases (48.9%) (table 2). Of these, 11 (23.4%) were due to bleeding from a single vessel and 12 (25.5%) were due to bleeding from multiple vessels. Bleeding was controlled by means of irrigation alone in five cases (10.6%) and required the use of electrocautery in 18 cases (38.3%). Intraoperative bleeding from a non-visualized source occurred in three cases (6.4%), each of which were controlled with continuous irrigation. Postoperative re-bleeding was noted in one patient (2.1%), on postoperative day 3, which resulted in re-accumulation of the hematoma. The bleeding in this patient, however, was thought to derive from a superficial extracranial vessel with communication intracranially through the burr hole, as a superficial hematoma was present at the incision site.
Minimally invasive hematoma evacuation has gained popularity through multiple small, but successful, prospective trials and iterative advances in technology that address the invasive drawbacks of the STICH trials technique.5 6 11 12 The advances in minimally invasive ICH evacuation have been well described previously.13 The technique reported here is a composite of previously described minimally invasive ICH evacuation techniques that also draws on neuroendoscopic strategies developed for use in other neurosurgical procedures, including intraventricular neuroendoscopy and transsphenoidal endoscopic surgery. The novelties of the SCUBA technique include the ability to visualize residual clot burden during evacuation, and clearly identify and cauterize bleeding vessels. Further investigation is needed to compare the SCUBA technique to existing minimally invasive ICH strategies to determine its relative performance in these areas.
Air versus fluid-filled evacuation
Most authors using the Apollo System have described working within an air-filled cavity during clot evacuation.10 14–16 Air-filled cavity endoscopic evacuation techniques without the Apollo System have also been described previously.17 However, Nagasaka and colleagues were the first to propose an alternative to the traditional air-filled cavity when they described the ‘balanced irrigation and suction’ technique.11 In this technique, when active bleeding is encountered, irrigation is increased to locate the bleeding vessel and, once found, firmly held in the suction cannula. The tip of the cannula is then electrified, which directly cauterizes the bleeding vessel. The balanced irrigation and suction technique permits the operator to search for bleeding vessels within the resection cavity and switch to an air-filled medium with aspiration before vessel ccauterization.
The SCUBA technique for attaining hemostasis of bleeding vessels within the hematoma cavity differs from Nagasaka’s balanced-irrigation suction technique. With the SCUBA technique, switching to an air-filled medium prior to cauterization of the bleeding vessel is unnecessary. Instead, cauterization is completed while the cavity remains filled with irrigation fluid, which is made possible by the true endoscopic nature of the SCUBA technique. Gentle irrigation and passive fluid egress through the endoscope clears the cavity of extravasating blood from the offending vessel and maintains visualization while still submerged. A cauterization device, introduced through the central endoscope port, is placed over the bleeding vessel to cauterize the source. Performing these technical maneuvers within a fluid-filled cavity facilitates detection of persistent bleeding from these vessels in real-time and offers confirmation that hemostasis has been achieved.
The SCUBA technique is adapted from continuous irrigation strategies used in intraventricular neuroendoscopy and transsphenoidal tumor resection.18 19 Locatelli and colleagues described a similar endoscopic ‘diving technique’ for transsphenoidal surgery in which continuous irrigation is used to create a fluid-filled cavity.18 The fluid-filled cavity used in the ‘diving technique’ permits the surgeon to evaluate the sella and intracranial skull base, wash blood from important structures, use intra-cavity pressure to quell cavernous sinus bleeding, and use the directed force of the irrigation stream to assist in tumor cleavage plane dissection. The SCUBA technique incorporates the advantages of the fluid-filled strategies used in these other forms of neuroendoscopic surgery and combines them with the previously described ICH air-filled cavity evacuation strategies.
SCUBA technique considerations
The SCUBA technique builds on previous techniques by combining stereotactic guidance, a low-profile endoscopic sheath, the Apollo System, electrocautery, and a fluid-filled cavity evacuation strategy. However, important considerations arise in response to the SCUBA technique. One concern cites that saline infusion into the hematoma cavity may cause increased intracranial pressure (ICP) or, at least, increased intracavity pressure, which may have the potential to injure viable perihematomal brain tissue. The accompanying unfavorable consequences of elevated ICP have been reported previously in the neuroendoscopic treatment of isolated IVH.19 The SCUBA technique allays concerns about this possibility by removing the majority of the hematoma and associated mass effect prior to activating any high-flow irrigation. Intracavity pressure can be monitored intraoperatively with a parenchymal ICP monitor, though this was not done for the cases described in this report.
A second point to consider is whether a greater hematoma evacuation percentage, as is the aim of the advantages offered by the SCUBA technique, is necessary for maximal improvement in functional outcome. In support of maximal evacuation, a subgroup analysis of the MISTIE II data demonstrated that increasing the evacuation percentage to greater than 70% led to improved functional outcome at 180 days compared with an evacuation percentage of 50% to 70%, which itself was better than <50%.20 Furthermore, animal data suggests that blood products are toxic to the surrounding brain, and implies that complete removal might be better than subtotal removal.21 Large randomized clinical trials in humans are needed to investigate this further. Until then, based on this evidence, it is reasonable to remove the maximum percentage of hematoma as is safely feasible.
The timeframe in which the evacuation procedure is performed is another important consideration. In a randomized study investigating ICH evacuation within 4 hours of symptom onset, ultra-early surgery led to higher perioperative rebleeding in comparison to surgery within 12 hours.22 As a result, many clinicians may opt to postpone the procedure until stability of the hematoma volume has been demonstrated. However, in contrast to the craniotomy evacuation procedure used in the aforementioned study, the endoscopic evacuation technique is less invasive. Studies have suggested that minimally invasive endoscopic techniques may improve neurologic outcomes in comparison to standard craniotomy evacuation.23 24 Furthermore, ultra-early minimally invasive endoscopic evacuation has shown safety and low rebleeding rates in subsequent studies.25 26 The SCUBA technique, a true endoscopic evacuation strategy, allows for the identification of bleeding vessels and direct cauterization within a saline-filled cavity. This technique may permit safe ultra-early hematoma evacuation by increasing the likelihood of identifying a bleeding artery. Additional investigations are needed to elucidate this crucial matter and determine whether ultra-early evacuation is of potential clinical benefit to patients.
Minimally invasive hematoma evacuation is a rapidly evolving management strategy for spontaneous ICH. The SCUBA technique represents a novel strategy utilizing the recently approved Apollo System and a fluid-filled cavity strategy for minimally invasive ICH evacuation. The fluid-filled cavity may offer advantages over air-filled and partially fluid-filled strategies that have been described previously, including clear identification and cauterization of bleeding vessels and visualization of residual clot burden, though further evaluation and comparison with existing techniques is required to determine its relative safety and efficacy.
CPK and AGC contributed equally.
Contributors All authors contributed to the manuscript through data collection, analysis, manuscript composition, and critical review. All authors provided final approval for publication.
Funding This research was supported in part by a grant from Arminio and Lucyna Fraga and by a grant from Mr. and Mrs. Durkovic.
Competing interests JM receives research grant support from Penumbra, Inc.
Patient consent Obtained.
Ethics approval Mount Sinai IRB.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.