Table 1

Patient characteristics

AuthorNumber of patients/femaleMean age (min
–max)
Mean BMI (min–max)Mean CSF opening pressure (min–max)Stenting as first
procedure
Mean gradient (min–max)FU monthsRisk of study bias (as measured by modified Newcastle–Ottawa Scale)
Higgins et al 13 200312/1233 (19–52)37 (29–45)34 (25–46)719 (8–37)14 (2–26)Moderate
Donnet et al 12 200810/842 (28–60)27 (22–37)40 (29–59)1019 (12–34)17 (6–36)Moderate
Bussière et al 11, 201010/1034 (16–65)36 (27–48)NR1028 (11–50)20 (4–60)Moderate
Ahmed et al 8 201152/4734 (10–64)NR32 (25–73)4319 (4–41)24 (2–108)Moderate
Albuquerque et al 14 201115/1231 (12–51)NRNRNRNR20 (2–40)Moderate
Fields et al 16 201315/1534 (20–56)39 (30–73)NR924 (13–40)14 (1–49)High
Ducruet et al 15 201430/2533 (14–52)NRNRNR21 (10–56)23 (3–59)Moderate
Goodwin et al 21 201418/1740 (21–56)33 (25–51)37 (25–55)1815 (0–42)9 (0–23)High
Teleb et al 22 201518/1530 (15–59)36 (23–59)NR1314 (1–40)25 (1–44)Moderate
Liu et al 23 201610/934 (17–59)42 (25–56)43 (27–55)630 (14–52)24 (16–32)Moderate
Bodduet al 10 201629/2830 (16–59)37 (19–52)NR2917 (9–37)26 (3–44)Moderate
Kumpe et al 17 18 2012 −201639/2836 (16–62)34 (NR)40 (NR)823 (10–43)27 (NR)Moderate
Aguillar-Pérez et al 24 201751/4140 (5–66)31(15-47)36 (19–60)4717 (1–39)49 (NR)Moderate
Satti et al 25 201743/3935 (21–54)35 (21–56)36 (14–56)3517 (7–46)14 (1–63)Moderate
Shazly et al 26 20176/632 (18–47)39 (33–43)40 (NR)629 (NR)6 (6–6)Moderate
Silva et al 27 20176/540 (22–53)NR40 (17–48)612 (9–17)11 (7–16)Moderate
Smith et al 28 201717/153035 (25–46)38 (26–55)1723 (13–41)18 (3–36)Low
Lenck et al 19 201721/1933 (NR)29 (NR)33 (NR)2114 (NR)14 (NR)Low
Asif et al 9 201741/3936 (19–55)NRNR2628 (NR)3 (3–4)Moderate
El Mekabaty et al 29 201731/2934 (18–67)39 (NR)NR3120 (NR)NRHigh
Totals474/4193535.27373422119
  • Figures are rounded to the nearest value.

  • NR, not recorded.